Important K 1.6.3: Post message success but not loading current thread

hi,
sorry for blurry title. i don't know how to make it clear in one sentence.
fyi,
im using j1.5.3 and kunena 1.6.3
im having this issue on certain thread. After post a message on a thread, it didn't load the thread but stuck at this screen:
[img]http://http://www.al-fikrah.net/media/kunena/attachments/63/redirect_error.jpg[/img]

after doing some investigation, i assume that the page stuck at kunena menu (without styles) but failed to show thread content.

it happen to certain thread. i cannot identify the polarity. some are long (many pages), some are short (5 replies).

after further investigation, i found that there is difference between success load and failed load.

here is the sample,

success load = mysite/index.php?option=com_kunena&func=view&catid=32&id=2937&Itemid=139#3329

failed load = mysite/index.php?option=com_kunena&func=post&Itemid=139

now i need to know how this happen in order to solve this issue...

Have you tried upgrading to K 1.7.1 to see if the upgrade solves your problems? See K 1.6 and K 1.7 Upgrade Guide

sozzled wrote: Have you tried upgrading to K 1.7.1 to see if the upgrade solves your problems? See K 1.6 and K 1.7 Upgrade Guide

i have successfully upgraded to 1.7 before but some problems occur after upgrade.
so i revert back to 1.6 by replacing the whole site.

i would be glad to have 1.7 on my site again. is there any simple way to upgrade and revert back in case there is a problem? replacing the whole site is not recommended.

What problems did you have after you went to K 1.7.1? Would it not be a better idea to work through those problems?

sozzled wrote: What problems did you have after you went to K 1.7.1? Would it not be a better idea to work through those problems?

thanks for your concern.
the problem is, when i click reply button, the page didn't load the editor (textbox). there's maybe already solutions on this issue, but i don't want to interrupt my forum, so i decided to continue with 1.6.

if there is a way to rollback update, then i would try it again.

I don't understand how K 1.7.1 failed to load the editor textbox. Could you show us a picture, please. It sounds like a fairly easy-to-fix problem but I want to be sure that I understand what you are talking about.

It would also help if you posted your K 1.7 configuration report here, too. It would be a real help if you could provide us with a test account so that we can see the problem first-hand. You can post details of your test account by using the confidential BBCode tag, like this:

right now im using k1.6.
after discussed with you, i got an idea to setup dummy live site (copying actual content) on my server to test 1.7 upgrade.

this method will not interrupt live 1.6 forum.

after finishing this process, i will give you the information.

i successfully upgraded to k1.7.
so far the problem went away. let's hope its gone forever.
the editor problem that i mentioned in previous post also gone.

i'll wait for more days to see the result.

thanks sozzled for your support.