Solved [k.5.0.RC4] Bug: Not able to approve a topic when edited

Tested with: PHP 7.0.8 + J.3.5.1 + K.5.0.RC4 + Crypsis

How to reproduce the error?
1. Open 2 different browsers or 2 browser instances and login with diferrent users on each one UserA/Browser1 and UserB/Browser2 (UserA=Moderator and UserB=Registered)

2. Make a new post with the UserB/Browser2

3. Approve the post with UserA/Browser1

4. Edit the post with UserB/Browser2

5. Approve the post with UserA/Browser1



Results:
Error in step 4. UserB/Browser2 will see a 403 forbidden page, it should be redirected to the parent category instead or allow access to see his topic with the pending status, or redirect to home page, anything but a 403 forbidden.

Error in step 5. UserA/Browser1 is not able to approve the post, even if the UserB/Browser2 logout.

The only way to approve it once edited is waiting a while or going back to unapproved list view (menu) and approve it from there.

Please note that this is an old bug from previous versions.

hm.. I cannot reproduce this error. All 5 steps work as desired.

Tested with Joomla 3.5.1, Joomla 3.6.0-rc2 and 3.7.0-dev
PHP 5.6 and 7.0.8
K.5.0.RC4 + Crypsis and K.5.0.RC5-DEV + Crypsis

The problem occurs in my production site that was recently migrated from k.4.xx to k.5.xx

I assume that you are testing with a clean installation of k.5.0.RC4
Am I right?
if that is the case, Can you please test with 4.0.11?

chiripas wrote: Tested with: PHP 7.0.8 + J.3.5.1 + K.5.0.RC4 + Crypsis

How to reproduce the error?
1. Open 2 different browsers or 2 browser instances and login with diferrent users on each one UserA/Browser1 and UserB/Browser2 (UserA=Moderator and UserB=Registered)

2. Make a new post with the UserB/Browser2

3. Approve the post with UserA/Browser1

4. Edit the post with UserB/Browser2

5. Approve the post with UserA/Browser1



Results:
Error in step 4. UserB/Browser2 will see a 403 forbidden page, it should be redirected to the parent category instead or allow access to see his topic with the pending status, or redirect to home page, anything but a 403 forbidden.

Error in step 5. UserA/Browser1 is not able to approve the post, even if the UserB/Browser2 logout.

First tested with K 4.0.11, then upgrade to K5.0

I confirm the 403 forbidden page, but only if its a new topic without another messages. In principle is it after edit a new unapproved topic.

rich wrote:
I confirm the 403 forbidden page, but only if its a new topic without another messages. In principle is it after edit a new unapproved topic.

Exactly.


For error in step 5, do you use cache?
I have these:
Joomla conservative Cache = ON
Kunena caching = YES
Apache mod_cache = YES
Opcache = YES

I am sorry, but I cannot reproduce step 5 (also tried with cache).

Ok my friend.
Do you have a email to send you my teamviewer credentials?

I never had to do something with teamviewer. I do not know it.

OK,
No problem