Kunena 7.1.1 & Kunena 6.4.17 – Security Updates Released

The Kunena team has announce the arrival of Kunena 7.1.1 [K 7.1.1] in stable which is now available for download as a native Joomla extension for J! 5.4.x/6.0.x./6.1.x./6.2.x This version addresses most of the issues that were discovered in K 6.2 / K 6.3 / K 6.4 / K7.0 and issues discovered during the last development stages of K 7.1
Just a reminder: K6.4.17 receives only securities fixes until end of 2026, so it's advised for users to upgrade to K7.1.

If you are having problems then, for your own benefit, it would save us all a lot of time if you would kindly post your configuration report when you ask for help from this forum. If you do not post your configuration report we will not ask you for it but you will probably not get your problem solved, either.

K 2.0 support will cease on 31 August 2013 and this section of the forum will be closed and archived after that time and no further questions will be answered about this version.

Question "Force users to pickup a category" - Usability issue

More
14 years 1 month ago #133765 by GJSchaller
I'm running into a user-based issue with "Force users to pickup a category".

If it is not enabled, people using the "New Topic" tab keep posting to the default category, even when they mean to post to somewhere else - even after repeated attempts to teach them to pick a category, they don't seem to get it.

If it's enabled, the opposite happens - other users who browse into a category that has children can't seem to post, because the selector forces them to choose from the current one, or a child category, and they aren't used to that behavior. To their mindset, if they are in a category, the topic belongs there.

I'd like to suggest setting the Category Selector to only appear on the New Topic tab, and NOT in a Category listing - the default assumption should be that if you start a new post from within a category, it belongs in that category, and not somewhere else. (Optionally, if it will default to the category you are in at the time, and only force you to select if you are at an Index or other place you cannot post, that would work too.)

I realize I can work around this by disabling the "Force users to pickup a category" option and turning off the New Post tab, but this seems a shame to disable useful features because they are confusing - I'd rather make them less confusing! :laugh:

Geoffrey Schaller
Technical Officer
Knight Realms

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
14 years 1 month ago #133766 by GJSchaller
Also, forcing someone to pick a topic once they are in a Category (versus posting from the New Topic tab) is an extra step that slows users down. It makes sense from the tab, because no topic is pre-selected, but it does not once you have already navigated into a Category.

Geoffrey Schaller
Technical Officer
Knight Realms

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
14 years 1 month ago - 14 years 1 month ago #133777 by sozzled

GJSchaller wrote: If it is not enabled, people using the "New Topic" tab keep posting to the default category, even when they mean to post to somewhere else - even after repeated attempts to teach them to pick a category, they don't seem to get it.

Welcome to our world! Before we implemented a number of important changes at www.kunena.org , we had endless problems of people posting in the first-listed category instead of using the forum index and category descriptions to help them choose the most appropriate category to use when creating new topics. The changes we made were:
  1. Remove the New Topic item from the Kunena menu. The result of this "forces" users to browse individual categories in order to locate the New Topic button.
  2. Reorganised the categories to give greater emphasis on the forum's primary purpose (namely the community self-help aspect); and
  3. Forum Configuration » Frontend » Look and Feel » Force users to pickup a category = Yes

Even now, after those changes, we still have people who "hope for the best" in choosing the category where they create their new topics. :laugh:

GJSchaller wrote: If it's enabled, the opposite happens - other users who browse into a category that has children can't seem to post, because the selector forces them to choose from the current one, or a child category, and they aren't used to that behavior. To their mindset, if they are in a category, the topic belongs there.

I'm not too sure about implication that users cannot create new topics in child categories. If you use www.kunena.org as an example of this issue, I don't believe that to be the case.

GJSchaller wrote: I'd like to suggest setting the category selector to only appear on the New Topic tab, and NOT in a category [index] ...

Well, hmmm, this is a tough one. It never worked successfully here at this site because even though the category selector is displayed every time a person creates a new topic, more than a "manageable-percentage" of the time the person creating the topic doesn't actually use it properly and this leads to an unacceptably high level of forum moderation overhead in a busy forum like the one here at www.kunena.org .

GJSchaller wrote: forcing someone to pick a topic once they are in a category [index] (versus posting from the New Topic tab) is an extra step that slows users down

We understand the trade-off involved but it hasn't much slowed the rate that people continue to create new topics here at this forum.

GJSchaller wrote: It makes sense from the tab, because no topic is pre-selected, but it does not once you have already navigated [to the index].

Arguably true but for other reasons I've mentioned, the benefits to this forum have outweighed the disadvantages. Our "solution" at K.org is not perfect but it was about the best we could achieve in a the quickest possible way.

Good topic worthy of further discussion/contribution from other members of the community.
Last edit: 14 years 1 month ago by sozzled.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
14 years 1 month ago #133809 by GJSchaller
I agree with most of your comments, Sozzled - I think the solution I've proposed will help simplify things and prevent confusion. The root issue I am seeing is that the choice, when present in a location where people aren't expecting a choice (already in a Category, pressing the "New Topic" icon for that Category), causes users to become confused. Removing it from this one location, and NOT from the New Topic tab in the Kunena Menu, will resolve the issue, while also allowing the "Force users to pickup a category" feature to still be useful in the Tab.

I see that the New Topic tab is not present on www.kunena.org - if it's turned off here, that indicates to me that there is something not usable about that feature, and it may merit further discussion / changes.

Geoffrey Schaller
Technical Officer
Knight Realms

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Time to create page: 0.116 seconds