Question Unaproved posts not working for reply k2.0.4

Hi folks, my Kunena topics needs moderations, so, I wonder also in K2.0.4 if is anybody else getting the issue when somebody replies a topic you don't get to see the topics that are waiting for approval. I mean, as administrator and using the menu "recent posts or topics" they don't show the replies waiting to be approved. I just know I have some reply to approve because I get an email notice.

Is anybody else facing the same issue on moderated topics (reply)?

Perhaps, if you include your configuration report, other people can compare their configurations with your and then they may be able to answer your question. I have not seen any other reports as you have mentioned.

As far as I know, if you have set a category (or categories) to be "Review Posts = Yes" then messages awaiting approval will not appear in the Recent Topics view until after they have been approved. That's just my guess. Isn't that what you want?

Hi Sozzled, good morning.

The categories are set this way you mentioned and when I create a menu item "Kunena Forum: Recent posts" and select in the dropdown list to show the "Unapproved posts", it should show/list all unapproved recent posts to be approved by an administrator, and it isn't happening as it was working before on the previous version of K2.0.3.

So, the moderation "Review Posts" is only working for new topics created by an user and not for replied topics even if the category is set as "Review Posts = Yes". So, as I said before, administrator is not getting to see the topics reply that are waiting for approval when using the menu item to list the recent posts or new topics. I just know that there are replies to be approved because I'm receiving emails informing it, otherwise the posts would never goes online and would get stuck in the approval queue.

Do you have some category here in this forum that needs ADM approval when an user reply and you are getting to see the grayed topics waiting for approval? I'm getting to see it in mine as it was expected to work and how it was working before.

Have a nice week.

There are two different Menu Types.

The Menu Item "Recent Topics" shows only unapproved topics.
The Menu Item "Recent Posts" shows unapproved topics and messages.

^ Both of them doesn't show moderated replies. I just know that I have replies to be moderated by a notice received by email, instead of having them showing when using The Menu Item "Recent Posts" shows unapproved topics and messages.

Did you mean the same?

I mean that topics created and moderated shows ok as your "testthema2", but when an user REPLY a topic, exampl your testthema 2, the reply also is moderated and the reply must be approved and listed in the unnaproved list and it isn't happening. As i said I just know that I have a reply to be approved by email notice, instead of having it show in the unnaproved list or the menu I've created. For example:

Sorry, I had tested with joomla 2.5. Now I have tested with Joomla 1.5 and can confirm your problem.
I have reported it on Git now.
github.com/Kunena/Kunena-2.0/issues/1386

Sorry me I didn't mention it was J1.5.25, but was on my signature. ;0)
Good to know Rich you got to see the issue and thanks for reporting it. I appreciated that.

Hope it get fixed on next update.

Cheers.